Rugby

Rugby Concussion Lawsuits Face Collapse Over Missing Documents

Rugby Concussion Lawsuits Face Collapse Over Missing Documents

Following years of expensive legal arguments, two lawsuits involving hundreds of brain-damaged rugby players are nearing collapse due to repeated delays in disclosing medical documents to defendants.

Lead counsel for the players, Paul Downes KC, previously admitted in June that the claimants were in the last-chance saloon after missing multiple court-mandated deadlines. Counsel representing World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union, and the Welsh Rugby Union argued that no further relief is available. The latest court hearings were intended to establish shortlists of potential test cases for a trial scheduled to begin next October. However, the defense stated they cannot proceed because they still lack necessary medical documents from the claimants, despite multiple court orders.

The hearings shifted focus toward whether the cases are now struck out due to breaches of court orders. Although the claimants previously received relief from this sanction, their legal representatives are now requesting an extension until January to achieve compliance. The outcome of the litigation depends on whether Senior Master Cook and Mr Justice Cotter decide to grant the extension.

KP Law took over representation for the players in June, replacing the previous firm, Rylands Garth. Downes described the case’s prior condition as shambolic and characterized the former firm’s work as an incredible failure. KP Law has submitted an additional 2,000 documents regarding medical testing, asserting that more progress occurred in the preceding 99 days than in the prior three years.

Despite these efforts, significant gaps remain. Court proceedings revealed that only 36 out of the 385 players in the union case possessed letters of diagnosis. Justice Cotter noted that it seemed remarkable anyone was onboarded without such a letter. Downes added that Rylands Garth maintained no universal database tracking provided documents and initially withheld files from KP Law pending an exit agreement involving fees.

Despite these setbacks, Downes maintained that the litigation remains salvageable. He submitted to the court that the case should be saved if possible.

More Stories for You