Special teams played a vital role in the Pittsburgh Penguins’ successful campaign last year, but both units have experienced significant struggles through the first 20 games of the 2026-27 season.
Decline From Last Year’s Success
During the previous season, the power play finished seventh in the league at 24.1%, while the penalty kill claimed the sixth spot at 81.4%, functioning as legitimate weapons alongside strong 5-on-5 play. Currently, the power play has dropped to 22nd in the NHL, and although the penalty kill sits at 13th, its recent performance trends are concerning.
Recent matchups highlight the unit’s regression. In a Nov. 8 game against the Anaheim Ducks, the penalty kill conceded three power-play goals, including a strike by Cutter Gauthier immediately after the Penguins failed to capitalize on a two-man advantage in the second period, contributing to a 5-2 defeat.
A similar scenario unfolded against the Vegas Golden Knights on Nov. 3. After squandering a two-man advantage late in the third period, the penalty kill allowed Tomas Hertl to score the game-winning goal with under a minute remaining, following Hertl’s earlier first-period power-play goal.
Tactical Issues on the Ice
The penalty kill unit has appeared overly passive in its own zone, frequently permitting opponents easy zone entries and quick setups. Once opposing teams establish control, the penalty killers fail to pressure puck carriers, allowing uncontested puck movement.
While the coaching staff aims to protect high-danger areas and prevent premium scoring chances, the lack of pressure allows skilled opponents to score from 20 to 25 feet out when shots go unblocked.
Coach Muse has built a career as a penalty kill specialist, giving him the expertise needed to correct these issues. Adjustments to the unit could help the team generate momentum and secure additional victories moving forward.








