Former England captain Michael Atherton believes Pat Cummins will not step down immediately as Australia’s Test cricket captain following renewed fallout from the 2018 Sandpapergate scandal. Speaking on the Sky Sports Cricket Podcast, Atherton stated that while Cummins faces mounting scrutiny over ball-tampering allegations, his position remains supported by Cricket Australia leadership.
Cricket Australia Support and Public Reaction
Cummins has faced calls to resign after denying assertions made by teammate Usman Khawaja and former opener Cameron Bancroft that the wider Australian squad knew ball tampering was occurring during their 2018 tour of South Africa. On November 13, Cummins dismissed Khawaja’s claims, describing them as “100 per cent wrong.” Bancroft subsequently issued a 4,000-word statement backing the allegations, adding that Cummins’ denials left him feeling “angry, betrayed and alone.”
Management representing Cummins released statements asserting that he has been “consistent and adamant” from the beginning and that the recent statement contained no unanswered points. Addressing Cummins’ future as captain, Atherton told Sky Sports that he does not view the position as under immediate threat.
“I don’t think so, yet,” Atherton said. “A few things are obvious. One, he has the support of Cricket Australia. David Boone [Cricket Australia interim chair], about a week ago, was very clear about that. On Wednesday, Boone and [Cricket Australia chief executive, Todd] Greenberg reiterated that very strongly. He’s obviously got a lot of credit in the bank in terms of performance as captain, having transformed the culture and kept Australia at the top of the tree, if you like.”
Atherton noted that public sentiment will play a significant role in how the situation unfolds. He suggested that sympathy may shift toward the players who served suspensions following the 2018 tour, particularly Bancroft, which could alter public perception of Cummins and the wider team leadership.
“Organisations are pretty fickle, aren’t they? They support you until you don’t. If the public turn on you, that can be a different thing,” Atherton added.
Dressing Room Environment and Bancroft’s Revelations
In his 4,000-word account, Bancroft stated that sandpaper was used during the second Test in Port Elizabeth as well as the third Test in Cape Town. He recounted discussions involving fast bowlers Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood, and Mitchell Marsh regarding ball movement, and recalled media manager Kate Hutchinson voicing opposition to the tampering plans in the presence of players and coaches.
Reflecting on the broader background, Atherton cited both Bancroft’s statement and Khawaja’s book, Sabr, as evidence of an institutional win-at-all-costs mindset that existed prior to the South Africa tour. Bancroft had made his Test debut during the 2017 Ashes series in Brisbane, entering what Atherton described as a environment filled with immense pressure. Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg acknowledged that the administrative body shared responsibility for the toxic dressing-room culture present at the time.
Atherton expressed sympathy for Bancroft, noting that a young player entering the national setup was left to take the blame alongside two teammates despite wider knowledge of the ball tampering within the squad.







