Football

St Mirren Boss Hits Out at SFA Reforms Dilution

St Mirren Boss Hits Out at SFA Reforms Dilution

St Mirren manager Craig McLeish has described it as “damning” that Scottish FA chief football officer Craig Mulholland must water down proposed reforms to accommodate clubs.

Concerns Over Club Self-Interest and Governance

Mulholland and the SFA have held discussions with Scottish Professional Football League clubs to promote increased playing time for young athletes, though media reports indicate the proposals have been weakened. McLeish stated that it is damning for Mulholland to change his plans to pander to clubs that lack enthusiasm for the initiative and fail to prioritize the national team’s interests.

The St Mirren boss noted that many owners and managers originate from outside the country and are fighting for their own clubs, questioning why those individuals control the future development of the national team. He argued that the current governance structure promotes self-interest at the top level and expressed pessimism about meaningful change.

The SFA had previously put forward proposals requiring two under-21 players to start in cup matches, alongside a mandate for the same age group to play at least 6% of available league minutes over a season. Scotland recently struggled in the Nations League campaign after reaching three of the last four major men’s tournaments, while Premiership clubs have failed to reach the Champions League proper in the past two seasons.

Flaws in Grassroots Coaching and Development

McLeish, who previously worked in St Mirren’s youth academy before taking charge earlier this year, emphasized that the country has a fundamental problem at the earliest age groups. He pointed out issues with how children are taught to play from ages four and five, formats, and a lack of education and expertise at the base of the pathway.

Comparing football to other activities, McLeish noted that sports like swimming or gymnastics provide access to properly qualified coaches and teachers who have operated at top levels. He acknowledged that grassroots football relies entirely on volunteers, but argued that these volunteers do not adequately teach children how to play properly.

The 36-year-old manager stressed that development between the ages of three and eight is critical, warning that failing to get it right at that stage makes subsequent progress impossible. The Press Association reported that it had contacted the SFA for comment regarding McLeish’s statements.

These remarks follow similar comments made by Dundee head coach Steven Pressley, who argued that Scottish football would benefit from a national football centre and compared the current structure to building on sand.

More Stories for You