College Football

NFL 2025 Draft First-Round Picks: Second-Year Busts and Stars

NFL 2025 Draft First-Round Picks: Second-Year Busts and Stars
Table of Content
  1. Cam Ward, QB, Titans
  2. Travis Hunter, CB/WR, Jaguars
  3. Will Campbell, OT, Patriots
  4. Ashton Jeanty, RB, Raiders
  5. Mykel Williams, EDGE, 49ers
  6. Shemar Stewart, EDGE, Bengals
  7. Omarion Hampton, RB, Chargers
  8. Matthew Golden, WR, Packers
  9. Tyleik Williams, DT, Lions
  10. Maxwell Hairston, CB, Bills

Evaluations of the top 2025 NFL Draft picks at the halfway point of their second seasons reveal that while players like Matthew Golden have emerged as stars, others such as Ashton Jeanty and Omarion Hampton have regressed. With contract extensions approaching for successful early picks and potential free agency looming for underperformers, players who had quiet rookie seasons face pressure to turn their careers around.

Cam Ward, QB, Titans

As reported by CBS Sports Headlines, Tennessee Titans quarterback Cam Ward is showing signs of a bounce-back after setting personal bests in passing yards and completion rate over his last two games. Head coach Robert Saleh noted that the team shifted philosophically to give Ward the opportunity to prove his franchise quarterback capabilities over the last three weeks. With Tennessee facing a decision in the 2027 draft, continued strong play could solidify his long-term future with the team.

Travis Hunter, CB/WR, Jaguars

Following a rookie season cut short by a torn LCL in October 2025, Jacksonville Jaguars two-way player Travis Hunter has fully recovered and flourished. Hunter ranks 11th league-wide in PFF defensive grade for cornerbacks, allowing a passer rating of just 52.8 across 35 targets and securing the first three interceptions of his career.

Will Campbell, OT, Patriots

New England Patriots offensive tackle Will Campbell is experiencing a quietly improved second season despite allowing season highs of six pressures, an 18.2% pressure rate, and two sacks in a loss to the Detroit Lions. Campbell’s overall season pressure rate and sacks allowed have decreased from 11.2% and 8.5 last year to 7.0% and 2.5 through 10 games.

Ashton Jeanty, RB, Raiders

Las Vegas Raiders running back Ashton Jeanty has regressed significantly during his sophomore campaign after recording a 41% rushing success rate, 975 yards, and five touchdowns as a rookie. Head coach Klint Kubiak has used Jeanty in a backfield timeshare alongside rookie Mike Washington Jr., resulting in Jeanty logging 123 carries for 380 yards and one touchdown alongside 46 receptions for 417 yards and three touchdowns.

Mykel Williams, EDGE, 49ers

San Francisco 49ers edge rusher Mykel Williams has struggled to make an impact following a rookie-season torn ACL that limited him to 14 career games and 2.5 sacks. Williams has not played more than half of all defensive snaps in any of his five appearances this season, prompting San Francisco to acquire DeForest Buckner at the trade deadline.

Shemar Stewart, EDGE, Bengals

Cincinnati Bengals edge rusher Shemar Stewart has seen his role dramatically decrease in 2026, recording just 52 defensive snaps all season and missing multiple games as a healthy scratch. Despite outstanding athletic testing at the NFL Draft Combine, the 17th overall pick has registered zero pressures, zero sacks, and just one tackle assist over his last five games played.

Omarion Hampton, RB, Chargers

Los Angeles Chargers running back Omarion Hampton has underperformed significantly in offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel’s system, experiencing drops in yards per carry, snap share, and success rate compared to his injury-shortened rookie year. Hampton tallied -46 rushing yards over expected in his first eight games, ranking 123rd among 132 running backs.

Matthew Golden, WR, Packers

Green Bay Packers wide receiver Matthew Golden has surpassed his entire 361-yard rookie total within the first five weeks of his sophomore season. The team’s first first-round wide receiver in 23 years ranks fifth in the NFL with 853 receiving yards and has broken 100 targets alongside CeeDee Lamb and Jaxon Smith-Njigba.

Tyleik Williams, DT, Lions

Detroit Lions defensive tackle Tyleik Williams has transitioned from a rotational player to a defensive anchor, helping lift the team’s rush defense into the top 10 in rushing EPA per play allowed. Williams ranks among the top 10 defensive linemen with at least 100 snaps against the run who have not missed a tackle all season.

Maxwell Hairston, CB, Bills

Buffalo Bills cornerback Maxwell Hairston has outperformed his rookie season in coverage metrics despite recording no interceptions and two passes defended. Hairston holds the lowest completion percentage allowed among Buffalo defensive backs targeted at least 10 times, alongside a -18.5% completion percentage over expectation.

More Stories for You