Calls are growing among New York Giants fans to replace rookie placekicker Dominic Zvada following recent struggles, but head coach John Harbaugh has preached patience while potential replacements remain limited. Zvada, who started his tenure making nine consecutive field goals, has connected on only eight of his past 14 attempts over the last four games, particularly struggling with kicks from the right hash mark.
Addressing the pressure to change kickers quickly, Harbaugh cautioned against hasty moves. “You can’t, as soon as a guy doesn’t make a play, start firing people left and right,” he stated.
Evaluating Free Agent Alternatives
Among fans, former Giants kicker Ben Sauls has frequently been suggested as a potential replacement. The left-footed Sauls stepped in late in the 2025 season, making all 15 of his kick attempts across three games, consisting of eight field goals and seven extra points. However, his longest successful attempt during that span was a 45-yard extra point, whereas Zvada has already been tasked with nine attempts from 50 yards or beyond, successfully converting six. Sauls also encountered severe technique issues in the spring and summer, regularly pulling kicks to the left, which ultimately led to Zvada winning the starting job. Sauls is currently not signed to any 53-man roster or practice squad.
Another candidate is 31-year-old veteran Zane Gonzalez, who spent eight seasons in the NFL and made 19 of 22 field-goal attempts for the Atlanta Falcons in 2025. Gonzalez was recently waived by the Miami Dolphins after missing two field goals and an extra point during a 24-22 loss to the Indianapolis Colts, having previously filled in for Riley Patterson earlier in the year.
Veterans and Practice Squad Candidates
Older available veterans include 42-year-old Matt Prater, who converted 18 of 20 field goals for the Buffalo Bills last season and last posted a field-goal percentage below 80 percent in 2020. Prater also connected on a 57-yard attempt for the Arizona Cardinals in 2024. Longtime veteran Graham Gano is also available as a free agent.
On practice squads around the league, Harrison Mevis is currently rostered by the Baltimore Ravens after going 5-for-9 in an earlier stint with the Los Angeles Rams this season. Additionally, Justin Tucker is currently with the Kansas City Chiefs. The former top-tier kicker under Harbaugh in Baltimore connected on 22 of 30 field goals in 2024 and served a suspension in 2025 related to sexual misconduct allegations.
With no clear superior alternative available on the market, the Giants face the prospect of resolving Zvada’s technique issues from the right hash mark rather than making a change at the position.







