The 2026 NFL trade deadline featured significant blockbusters that altered the Super Bowl race, but several high-profile deals ultimately failed to materialize. Teams held onto multiple star players after rejecting trade inquiries or failing to reach agreements before the clock ran out. According to CBS Sports Headlines, these retained players immediately transform into key trade candidates for the upcoming offseason window that opens in the spring.
Jonathan Taylor and Top Offensive Trade Candidates
Jonathan Taylor of the Indianapolis Colts was widely expected to be the most sought-after player at the deadline. The Colts turned down interest from multiple suitors because they did not receive the first-round pick they wanted in return. The three-time Pro Bowler carries no guaranteed money on his contract for 2027 or 2028, making him a valuable rebuilding asset. Having reportedly rejected offers involving second-round picks, Indianapolis will likely command at least a first-rounder if they entertain trades for him next year.
George Pickens of the Dallas Cowboys is another marquee name who stayed put. Owner Jerry Jones opted against signing him to a long-term extension last offseason and could use the franchise tag, but Pickens may seek a lucrative multi-year deal elsewhere if hesitation persists. Meanwhile, the Tennessee Titans fielded inquiries on Tony Pollard, but kept the 29-year-old running back following back-to-back 100-yard games with five total touchdowns. Pollard can leave in free agency, putting him on a different timeline than the team’s younger offensive pieces.
Brian Thomas Jr. of the Jacksonville Jaguars saw his target share drop behind other receivers after a strong rookie season. Because the Jaguars are contending for a Super Bowl, they chose to keep their lineup intact rather than deal him in the final year of his contract. In Tennessee, Calvin Ridley has been phased out of the receiving corps behind several younger pass-catchers and tight ends. Ridley’s dead cap hit drops from $22.5 million to $7.5 million this spring, which could pave the way for a parting of ways.
Defensive Stars and Edge Rushers to Watch
Will McDonald IV of the New York Jets requested a trade on the eve of the deadline due to frustration over his playing time. General Manager Darren Mougey kept him despite interest from teams like the Jacksonville Jaguars. With the Jets featuring David Bailey for the future, McDonald could renew his trade search in the offseason.
The Los Angeles Chargers surprised many by keeping their core intact despite a dismal 0-8 record. Khalil Mack drew interest, but the Chargers showed no interest in moving him, leaving the veteran edge rusher a prime candidate to seek a contender in free agency. In Arizona, Budda Baker remains with the Cardinals as the team shifts toward a younger direction. Set to turn 31 when the 2027 league year begins, Baker would yield a strong draft return to help build around an incoming rookie quarterback.
Riq Woolen played a solid pass defense role for the Philadelphia Eagles, though his 103.3 passer rating allowed marks a career-worst regression from his Seattle Seahawks days. His impending free agency could net Philadelphia a compensatory draft pick if he departs. Finally, Josh Sweat stayed with the Arizona Cardinals through the deadline. Although Sweat requested a trade last spring over a contract dispute, the team quelled those narratives, but his status will remain worth monitoring when the new league year begins.
The next trade window officially opens in the spring at the start of the 2027 league year, giving teams another opportunity to pursue these players.
