Baseball

10 Most Interesting MLB Non-Tender Decisions Ahead of Deadline

10 Most Interesting MLB Non-Tender Decisions Ahead of Deadline

The deadline for Major League Baseball teams to offer contracts to arbitration-eligible and pre-arbitration players marks a crucial point on the offseason calendar. Players must receive a contract offer by the deadline or become non-tendered free agents, a fate that dozens of players face annually when teams determine their production no longer matches their salary expectations according to CBS Sports Headlines.

Top Non-Tender Candidates Facing Important Offseason Decisions

The list of interesting non-tender decisions highlights players whose recent performance or salary projections put them at risk, utilizing data from MLB Trade Rumors. Teams typically attempt to trade these players before making any non-tender official.

Jarren Duran of the Boston Red Sox carries a projected salary of $11.1 million with team control through 2028. After a Jake Bauers signing crowded the roster, Duran sits among a group of eight players competing for five lineup spots. Despite receiving MVP votes in 2024 and recording a 20-20 season in 2026, Duran saw his strikeout rate climb and his on-base percentage drop to .266. Having been on the trade block for nearly two years, he faces a strong possibility of a non-tender if Boston cannot execute a trade.

Detroit Tigers first baseman Spencer Torkelson holds a projected salary of $7.7 million with control through 2028. Non-tendering a former No. 1 overall pick drafted by the franchise would be an unusual move for the organization. Torkelson, 27, provides 25 to 30 home runs per year but struggles with a high strikeout rate and limited secondary value, though a lack of an obvious internal replacement could help him stay.

New York Yankees right-handed pitcher Luis Gil projects at a modest $2.3 million with control through 2029. The 2024 American League Rookie of the Year battled injuries and a declining fastball swing-and-miss rate over the past two seasons, leading to a late-season move to the bullpen and time in Triple-A. Because he is out of minor-league options and lacks a clear role, New York may seek a trade partner or consider a non-tender.

Ernie Clement of the Toronto Blue Jays has a projected salary of $7.6 million and control through 2028. The fan favorite and 2026 All-Star slumped offensively in the second half, maintaining a .295 on-base percentage over three full seasons while seeing his defensive metrics decline. While his elite contact skills make him a valuable utility player, the salary is steep for a reserve role.

Royce Lewis of the Minnesota Twins projects at $5.1 million with control through 2028. Another former No. 1 overall pick, Lewis has trended downward since 2023, resulting in a demotion to Triple-A and a defensive move from third base to first base. A fresh start could benefit Lewis, allowing the budget-conscious Twins to reallocate funds.

Pitchers and Power Hitters on the Bubble

Nolan Gorman of the St. Louis Cardinals carries a projected salary of $3.4 million with control through 2028. After slugging 27 home runs in 2023, Gorman failed to replicate that success and spent significant time in Triple-A due to contact struggles. With the Cardinals reportedly seeking a stopgap third baseman, paying a high price for a reclamation project bound for the minors is questionable.

Jake Burger of the Texas Rangers projects at $6.9 million with control through 2028. Approaching age 31, Burger offers rare right-handed power with at least 28 home runs in three of the last four years, but brings low batting averages and no defensive value. Rangers president of baseball operations Chris Young emphasized a desire for grinders who challenge pitchers, potentially making Burger too expensive for his limited skill set.

Camilo Doval of the San Francisco Giants has a projected salary of $6.6 million with control through 2027. Following stints with the Yankees, Pirates, and Giants, the former All-Star closer has pitched primarily as a middle reliever recently. Because rules limit a salary cut to a maximum of 20% during team control years, setting a $4.88 million minimum, the Giants might push for a negotiated pay cut to avoid a non-tender.

Gavin Sheets of the San Diego Padres projects at $6.5 million with control through 2027. The 30-year-old serves mostly as a platoon player against right-handed pitching and carries defensive liabilities at first base and left field. While the sum is not massive in a broader context, it represents top-of-the-market pay for a designated hitter platoon role.

Ronel Blanco of the Houston Astros rounds out the group with a projected salary of $1.4 million and control through 2029. Two years after throwing a no-hitter early in his career, Blanco returned from Tommy John surgery to a diminished role that saw him pitch just once in Houston’s final 12 games. Despite his low cost and remaining minor-league option, his late-season usage leaves his future with the club in question.

More Stories for You