Hockey

Pittsburgh Penguins Face Crossroads as ‘Big Three’ Era Winds Down

Pittsburgh Penguins general manager Kyle Dubas acknowledged that the struggling franchise is undertaking a rebuild as the team sits near the bottom of the Eastern Conference with three regulation wins through 20 games. Speaking on Wednesday, Dubas stated that progress this season will be measured by younger players taking major steps and prospects earning NHL playing time, rather than simply making the playoffs.

A Balancing Act Nearing its End

Dubas used the word rebuild for the first time publicly since taking over in the summer of 2023, describing the effort to point toward the future without tarnishing the legacy of longtime core players Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, and Kris Letang as an unorthodox style of rebuilding. With the Penguins struggling to gel after a surprising playoff berth last spring, Dubas warned that if the team continues on its current path, future-oriented transactions will follow.

That shift in strategy could see the team trade notable veterans who are not part of the long-term future. Forward Rickard Rakell and three-time Norris Trophy-winning defenseman Erik Karlsson are among those likely to attract interest, though Karlsson noted that the trade speculation is simply part of the reality when results fall short.

Aside from a season-opening victory against Philadelphia, the Penguins have struggled defensively and their power play remains inconsistent. While 40-year-old Malkin has looked fresh, captain Sidney Crosby has not reached his usual elite production level, needing a strong stretch to extend his NHL record of averaging at least a point per game to 22 consecutive seasons.

Uncertain Future for Crosby

Crosby is currently 25 points away from passing Hall of Famer Ron Francis for fifth place on the NHL’s all-time scoring list, but he has yet to sign a contract extension as he contemplates how much longer he wants to play. Dubas emphasized that Crosby deserves complete respect and noted that the franchise will leave the decision entirely up to the three-time Stanley Cup champion.

While the organization has attempted to keep the competitive window open while developing new talent, it has not yet secured the kind of transformative prospect that historically defined the franchise from the eras of Mario Lemieux and Jaromir Jagr to Crosby and Malkin. Crosby acknowledged that the team is trying its best to find solutions, even as the clock ticks down on the current generation of Penguins hockey.

The Penguins host the St. Louis Blues on Thursday looking to show signs of life and avoid a definitive pivot toward a full roster teardown.

More Stories for You