Baseball

A’s Face Tough Trade Dilemma to Improve Starting Rotation

A’s Face Tough Trade Dilemma to Improve Starting Rotation
Table of Content
  1. Henry Bolte
  2. Lawrence Butler
  3. Zack Gelof
  4. Shea Langeliers
  5. Brent Rooker
  6. Tyler Soderstrom
  7. Jacob Wilson

The A’s face severe limitations in improving their starting rotation due to their current home field, recent records, and modest payroll, yet they recognize they cannot compete without vastly upgrading their pitching staff. This dilemma leaves the new front office with a tempting but dangerous choice: dip into their pool of talented position players to land a quality starting pitcher. As reported by sports.yahoo.com, doing so would weaken a lineup that already struggled away from hitter-friendly ballparks, finishing last in all of Major League Baseball in batting average, on-base percentage, and slugging percentage.

Henry Bolte

Trading Henry Bolte would mean losing the only center fielder who can hit well and the only true leadoff hitter on the roster. Bolte proved himself as a legitimate center fielder in his rookie season with strong defensive metrics and impressive hitting numbers, including a .277 batting average and .359 on-base percentage. At just 23 years old with six years of contract control remaining, trading him could yield a sizable return, but it would leave a major gap in the outfield since he has only 119 big league games under his belt and might not command an actual ace.

Lawrence Butler

Lawrence Butler is the most enigmatic player in the group, having endured a difficult first half of 2026 before bouncing back strongly after the All-Star break. His contract leaves five years and $12 million with a $4 million buyout, creating a potential liability alongside his huge swings in performance that lower his overall trade value. Consequently, he is likely not the right player to move until he starts the 2027 season strong and rebuilds his value, especially since trading him would likely bring up Devin Taylor as a replacement.

Zack Gelof

Zack Gelof frequently appears in trade rumors due to his defensive versatility, having excelled at second base, third base, and center field. At the plate, he bounced back with a .256/.322/.475 batting line and his career-lowest strikeout rate of 24.6%. Because his strong defense makes him a positive contributor even when his bat is quiet, teams would likely give up a fair bit to acquire him, though the A’s infield lacks the depth to easily absorb his loss before prospect Leo De Vries returns from shoulder surgery.

Shea Langeliers

Shea Langeliers is considered one of the top overall catchers in the American League and would command a significant return with two full years left on his contract. His trade value likely remains intact despite a knee injury and September struggles, but the A’s have no immediate primary replacement in their system. Moving Langeliers would mean accepting a massive drop-off at the catcher position for the foreseeable future, making it a difficult choice even if interested teams are willing to offer a quality starting pitcher.

Brent Rooker

Brent Rooker serves as a major clubhouse leader for the team, making a trade unlikely anytime soon. His trade value has declined following an okay 2025 season, a disastrous start to 2026, and season-ending surgery. Furthermore, as a designated hitter who struggles defensively in the outfield, he holds significantly more value to the A’s than to other clubs, and no team is expected to offer the high-end pitching the A’s covet in exchange for him.

Tyler Soderstrom

Tyler Soderstrom is a natural trade candidate because he has generally performed when healthy, possesses a team-friendly contract controlled through at least 2032, and has Devin Taylor waiting in the wings to play the outfield corner. However, questions remain regarding his outfield defense following a significant drop in defensive metrics during the 2026 season, alongside concerns about whether a hip impingement is fully resolved. Additionally, trading him would further deplete a heavily right-handed A’s batting core.

Jacob Wilson

Jacob Wilson is another core player frequently discussed as a potential trade chip for starting pitching after starting the 2025 All-Star game and setting an ongoing record for consecutive errorless games at shortstop. Despite his talent, his stubborn lack of plate discipline and limited range resulted in an 83 wRC+ before he hit the injured list. Moving Wilson would leave the infield short-handed unless other players step in to cover the gaps at second or third base.

Decisions regarding whether to use any of these players as trade chips to bolster the rotation or stand pat with the core rest with Taylor Smith and Cam Castro, with any potential trades needing to happen in November or wait until March.

More Stories for You