Table of Content
Ten games into the Premier League season, four of the top five places belong to traditional big-six clubs, with only second-placed Brighton and ever-presents Everton challenging their dominance. In pure financial terms, this outcome comes as no surprise since the six biggest clubs generate hundreds of millions of pounds more than the division’s other teams, and that gap grows every single season.
The Widening Revenue Gap
Companies naturally direct their money where supporters spend it, and Liverpool, Arsenal, and Manchester United traditionally dominated viewing figures, column inches, shirt sales, and sponsorships in England. Over the past twenty years, Chelsea, Manchester City, and Tottenham have joined this elite group, generating massive revenue streams that make long-term failure difficult to imagine.
Using Everton as a benchmark, BBC Sport highlighted how founding members of the league have been left trailing far behind. The revenue gap between the big-six average and Everton grew from £120m in 2009-10 to £442m in 2024-25. Kieran Maguire, a professor of football finance at the University of Liverpool, told BBC Sport that this massive escalation is largely driven by the boom in international television rights and global fanbases that attract lucrative commercial partners.
“The big football brand clubs have global fanbases and that makes them very attractive to global commercial partners, especially for sponsorship and front-of-shirt deals,” Maguire said, noting that the Premier League’s broadcast reach across 190 countries helps clubs negotiate excellent prices. While commercial deals make up 45% of big-six revenue, they account for only 10% of Everton’s revenue, leaving clubs like Everton heavily reliant on broadcast income.
Champions League Rewards and Chelsea’s Stadium Problem
Although Aston Villa and Newcastle have started increasing their revenues thanks to Champions League football, UEFA’s system entrenches the position of the biggest clubs through the value pillar, which reserves 35% of all Champions League revenues—amounting to £713m—for historically successful clubs. At the end of the previous league phase, Manchester City earned an estimated £37.9m from the value pillar, Liverpool £35.5m, and Chelsea £33.3m, whereas Newcastle received just £13.6m.
Meanwhile, financial trends show Chelsea beginning to fall behind, recording the lowest revenues among the big six in the past two seasons—£74m behind Tottenham and £200m below Liverpool and Manchester City. While Manchester City’s huge revenues stem from commercial deals, their matchday income is the lowest, and the club has been found guilty of breaching Premier League financial rules between 2009-10 and 2017-18 by inflating values using sham contracts (an allegation the club denies and is appealing). Chelsea’s primary issue is stadium capacity, as Stamford Bridge holds only 40,000 seats with no easy expansion scope, whereas the rest of the big six hold at least 60,000.
“Matchday spend has become increasingly important,” Maguire told BBC Sport, explaining that flatlining broadcast revenues since 2017 forced clubs to seek alternative income sources. While Chelsea’s matchday revenue rose by only £16m over ten years, United’s grew by £69m and Spurs’ by £85m. Consequently, Chelsea relies far more heavily on player sales, though successful player trading has limited the immediate financial impact.
Impact of New Squad-Cost Rules
Squad-cost ratio (SCR) has replaced the old profit and sustainability rules (PSR) this season, allowing clubs to spend the money they generate on players rather than being restricted by strict loss limits. Maguire explained that while SCR makes it slightly easier for clubs like Villa and Newcastle to spend, the system remains heavily weighted in favor of the big six. Most big-six clubs sit well below the Premier League’s 85% SCR limit.
This increased spending capacity has heavily influenced the transfer market, with Premier League clubs spending £3.5bn over the summer to nearly break the full-season record of £3.53bn set in 2025-26. Transfer amortisation has more than doubled and nearly tripled over the past decade, bringing the average cost in SCR calculations to just under £100m. UEFA fears SCR will cause widespread inflation across Europe, a concern underlined by 13 Premier League clubs breaking their transfer records over the summer, including £40m-plus outlays by Brentford, Brighton, Palace, Leeds, and Nottingham Forest.
Despite the massive financial disparity, clubs like Brentford and Brighton demonstrate that smart models—signing potential stars, nurturing them, and selling them to the big six—can compete effectively against larger wallets. However, Maguire noted that smaller margins for error make it a precarious business for smaller sides. “The big six can afford to make signings which are £60m and £70m, who turn out to be relative flops, and still have those players on high wages for several years,” Maguire stated.
Commercial power does not guarantee immediate success, as demonstrated by Manchester United sitting in the relegation zone despite manager Mauricio Pochettino potentially receiving another chance to revamp a squad following £945m in player spending over five years. The richest clubs retain the luxury of spending their way out of trouble repeatedly, whereas the rest of the league remains only a couple of bad transfer windows away from financial catastrophe.








